The subject of whether flying actually provides a substantial time benefit over taking the train between Edinburgh and London has long been debated among travelers. That argument has recently been reignited by a UK travel YouTuber’s experiment, which shows that the two options’ total travel times are much closer than most people think.
How the Test Was Performed
With a stopwatch, Scott Manson, the creator of the channel Planes, Trains, Everything, left Edinburgh’s Princes Street and clocked the two trips from door to door. This included the final stretch into central London, transfers, security lines, and the walk to the station or airport. In order to ensure that the comparison accurately depicted the travel rather than depending on predetermined timings, he stopped the clock close to Oxford Street.
Train vs. Aircraft: The Difference in Timing
According to AviationAnalysis.net’s comprehensive timings, the train trip took 4 hours, 53 minutes, and 25 seconds, which is just less than the standard 5-hour time frame. The British Airways jet had a lead of just a few minutes after completing the same city-to-city-to-city-center trip in 4 hours, 49 minutes, and 22 seconds.
Comfort and Consistency
In spite of the short time difference, Manson said the train was the more comfortable choice. He found London City Airport to be congested and unpredictable, primarily because of security lines and traffic, as HeadTopics summarizes. The experience on the train was simpler and more serene.
The Difference in the Environment
Emissions showed one of the biggest variances. According to Manson’s calculations, the flight created around 165 kg of CO2, whereas the train produced roughly 12.5 kg. The environmental benefit of the rail alternative is further enhanced when the time savings offered by flying are so minimal.
How Much Does It Cost?
Cost was also a significant factor. The train cost about 60 pounds when reservations were made in advance, while the flight cost about 95 pounds. Fares for both increased significantly as the trip date approached, but when airport transfers were added to the equation, flying became even more costly.
The Last Word
Technically, the flight recorded the faster time, but the difference was so little that even a small delay may have changed the outcome. On the Edinburgh-London route, the train is still a very competitive option for those looking for a more tranquil, environmentally friendly, and frequently more affordable option.
